Subway is a familiar go-to for office lunches and group orders in NYC. Subway catering is fast, affordable, and easy to customize. But if you’re looking to switch things up, stretch your budget further, or find sandwich catering that better fits your team’s tastes, there are plenty of strong alternatives worth considering.
New York City has no shortage of great, low-cost sandwich catering options that deliver the same convenience as Subway—often with better portions, more variety, or more crowd-pleasing menus. Below, we’ve rounded up some of the best Subway sandwich alternatives for catering in NYC, all ideal for feeding groups without overthinking it.
Affordable NYC Sandwich Catering Options in NYC
Boujee Sandwiches from Eat Street NYC
With a near perfect 4.94 / 5.00 star review score on CaterCow, you are almost guaranteed a flawless experience. Eat Street hooks it up with expertly crafted sandwiches made with premium ingredients. Think mortadella, prosciutto, and thick-cut fresh mozzerella. For just $10, Eat Street Boujee Sandwiches are among the most affordable sandwiches on CaterCow.
Signature Sandwich and Wrap Platters from Mealz
Choose from 18 different signature sandwiches and wraps. With 7 Gluten-Free options, and 2 vegetarian sandwiches this is a hit when team members have dietary restrictions. At $9.99 per person, it's $0.50 cheaper than a Subway Sandwich Lunch Box. Mealz has been on the scene since 2022 and is growing a fervent following.
Gourmet Sandwiches from Caffe Bene
For those looking for gourmet sandwich catering in NYC, Caffe Benne offers boundless options across 34 different sandwiches, giving even Subway in NYC a run for its money on variety of options. Customers describe their catering options simply "the best". We love the variety of breads used, tailored to the sandwich and the option for gluten-free bread.
